From Porn To Pep Boys: The Rise And Fall Of Gay Porn Superstar Samuel O’Toole

Not again?! Yes, again. The mass Next Door Studios exodus continues with yet another fired model: Samuel O’Toole. While Sammy shared the news of his leaving Next Door weeks ago, it wasn’t until today that he announced he wasn’t just leaving the failed mega studio, he was leaving all of gay porn for good. His new job? An assistant manager at Pep Boys.


Meanwhile, someone claiming to be from Unzipped Media (which no longer exists) was trying to extort nude photos from Samuel O’Toole, which is kind of a waste of time because, uhh, hello? And then Samuel O’Toole said he would shoot them.

Watch out!

AND:

Samuel O’Toole’s first video of all time. Goodbye forever, Sammy!

[SamuelO’Toole.com]

 

60 thoughts on “From Porn To Pep Boys: The Rise And Fall Of Gay Porn Superstar Samuel O’Toole”

  1. First of all he may have left porn but it hasn’t left him, it will be out there forever all of the videos he made and he is still all over the web he can’t take it down belongs to the studios so even if he has children they will grow up and one day see all of his porn on the web . It won’t go away it’ll be there the rest of his life and even after he’s dead and gone it will still come up as him being an ex gay pornstar . That is on the web forever there are pornstars that have been dead for 40 years that still come up on the web you can’t get rid of it you’ll be known as a gay WHORE WHO SOLD HIS BODY FOR MONEY. Talking about leaving a bad taste in his mouth that looks like to me he was enjoying it in his mouth pretty good !!!!!!

    1. WOW!! Theres always got to be a sour lemon in the batch and unfourtnatly in the gay communnity (hahaha) they’er groves! You cant be blackmaled for something that your not ashamed of. If he gets married/children whatever it dosent mean they’ll find out. Of course you bitter evil trolls/queens will MAKE SURE to blab it to everyone you know as a negitive thing. I was watching a show on HGtv, And kept going “why does he look familar?” Ahhh now I remember. Good for him he’s had an experience and then went on with his llife!! Didnt stop Joe Dallesandro or Slyvester Stalone so I wish him/them/both nothing but the best!

  2. what have you done to this very beautiful human being,where is tolerance,love and understanding,for me i pray to God that he will be alright,that he will be always happy,healthy,wealthy and very successful in all his life endeavors,my sympathy to him and his whole family that he loves ,am sure.let us propagate love,peace,goodwill,i understanding and forgiving as a simply human being-i hope and pray that the lord be with him.protect him,guide him and grant him all the best in his life,God cares for the little birds how much more with us,TO err is human to forgive is divine,Tolerance please.Whatever let us wish him in silence,all the best wishes to Samuel 0″Toole.good luck,good health and Godspeed.Wish you the best job you wanted to do.

    1. I like Samuel O’Toole’s vids. Wish him all the best things in life. Wish everyday will bring him new happiness.

  3. Castrate him with a Burdizzo, takes only ten seconds to squeeze the spermatic cords leading to each stone. As he is very strong in the rod its best to use a full size Burdizzo pincers to cut him.

  4. The thing is that most gays dont get because they are so lost in the fantasy of having sex with a straight man, or possibly turning him is, really truly straight men do not have sex with other men, period! All these guys that are having sex with other guys are not straight or even close to straight. In porn, the idea is that you have to progress slowly but surely to the point to where you just have to be turned inside out sexually. You literally have to go to the point on film to where youre cum covered and you have cum leaking out every hole in your body and at the same time enjoy it onscreen. These guys that go the Cody Cummings route, no matter how hot and how good they look, cannot fool the gay people for very long, hence their porn life doesnt last long. NDS tried to build a corporation on hoping to fool the gays into throwing their money away on this fake porn. In the end its all a huge turn off to me. Do these studios think I’m so hard up for porn that I need to look at some morons saying they are straight? No thanks I’ll take my money elsewhere, or just DL stuff for free. Good riddance you dumb ass, and good luck in the real world. Before its all said and done I’m sure his asshole will be hanging down to his knees because he will learn to be the best bottom in North America.

  5. Sammy had stated he just doesn’t like the feeling of bottoming.I know that may be to hard for some to believe buy some don’t like bottoming and are gay or bi.he’s said he’d date a man our a woman just depended on the person.plus he said he had no interest on dating anyone while on porn.everyone along for such quotes only need go to his youtube channel he answers fan questions.he’s actually pretty funny and smart and down to earth.

  6. He is a useless little piece of nonsense and will end up dead from self-hate. Anyone who has to continue tweeting with his porn name after resigning porn in favor of a civilian life with mundane details of his “new life” journey is a fraud and should be ignored> He’s just not that interesting.

  7. I thought Samuel was beginning to look really good with his scruffiness. :/ The Pepboys graphic KILLED ME though hahahahaha!!

    1. what are you thinking

      Well, that is what we call PR spin… to make yourself apparently nicer, honest, and a victim of circumstance than you truly are. All who followed his twitter and blogs, were basically used for the purpose of spin and to drive membership to his site. Now that his site is a porn library, and he is no longer employed by NDS to produce more content, he won’t give a shit about keeping in touch with anyone.

      1. what are you thinking

        FYI: the blog and twitter accounts are managed by NDS staff additionally. You can pretty much tell when the staff have taken over the blog or twitter when the scenes or other related marketing shit is posted.

        On his blog, just look for “Hey Everybody!” in the opening line.
        And on his twitter, the shit that gets posted with a link referring back to the site.

        Incidentally, the twitter account was deleted briefly, but a day or so later was reinstated by the company. I’m sure Samuel had a hissy fit and decided to delete the account. Also, the “bad taste” comment was removed and replaced with another tweet that stated he had no “ill” will towards anyone.

        Plus, his fans would want to know NDS owns his likeness and Samuel O’Toole name. So he isn’t going to be blogging anytime soon. It was probably revealed to him, and as a result left him with a “bad taste” in his mouth.

        You can assume the remaining models like Sam, who were fired, have their accounts actively managed by the studio. And of course, why inconsistent statements were posted earlier by the models themselves that were later recanted. Tyler was one of them that posted some shit, that the studio removed.

    1. what are you thinking

      Well, in the internet age, porn is not exactly a public acknowledged phenomenon. It is relegated to the darkest corners of our bedrooms and offices that are connected to the internet. Anyone outside wouldn’t want to be associated with it, nor would they come forward and ask an NDS star for an autograph in the supermarket checkout line. It would be embarrassing.

      And like the rest of the NDS talent pool, Samuel was sent out on group appearances for the studio, only to promote the studio itself. His work is primarily associated with the studio. Now that he doesn’t have a job with them, his options are limited since he doesn’t do anything “remarkable” except show off his fat dick; and in porn, this a dime a dozen, as there are plenty of performers who mold their dick into dildos too. He doesn’t raise the bar in performances, and only performs in the top role(like the majority of his NDS peers). Which is ridiculous, because some of his scene partners towered over him, and it was humorous to watch those scenes with Samuel topping.

      Also, since the beginning, his online remarks and blogging left myself and others the impression that he is a ditz and lacked commonsense. This was usually because he attempted to be witty and funny, which typically falls flat in text. Nor was his political and philosophical ideas he shared online helpful image wise, as those opinions made him appear self absorbed. It would be better if he didn’t talk so much. This is a common problem with a lot of porn talent.

  8. The fact that he actually thought that he was too dumb to figure out that Unzipped Media hasn’t existed in several years tells me he is either making this up or really is that dumb. The nude photos “extortion” story sounds like bullshit. I wonder if some of his decision to leave has to do with a post on TheDirty.Com about him and his other Next Door Friends that includes his real name as well as the name of his mother. If you google his real name it’s the fourth entry down on a google search page. Uh….good luck with that one with potential employers.

  9. Karl Rove's Mama's Dead Vag

    Bless his ittyness. Love “conceal carry” comment. Lollipop Guild & their shiny cap guns from ‘Dances With Wolves’ collectible holster set. Out blowing folks’ kneecaps off. On weed? lol.

    1. Your comment sounds like a vision of a jumping and colorful ‘ dead vag ‘ among lots of weed’s smoke. Keep posting…

  10. I kindna wish Pep Boys had hired him so he can take that jack-ass Cody-Cumming with him.And all those other G4pers as well so we would never have to see them again? I’ve never bought into his lie that he is Bisexual any way it was just a bad lie to keep his gay fan base happy that’s all and now that he has decided to leave gay-porn for good make it even better.I just wish other g4pers in gay-porn would follow his lead and retire too.The more g4pers leeches that leave gay-porn the better? Are you listening Cody-Cumming because your next! It’s just a matter of time.

    1. what are you thinking

      Homosexuality, Bisexuality, and Heterosexuality are not limited to sexual practice. They are apart of behaviors that include romantic relationships.

      A true bisexual would pursue romantic relationships with either men or women. He doesn’t do this at all. His basic philosophy is free love, without the icky emotion part. Basically casual sex, only with more options.

  11. If Next Door is a “failed mega studio” does that mean all the other Gamma mega studio sites will also be failing soon?

  12. Well, I figured this one was going to leave as soon as it became known Next Door Asswipes was closing up shop. When he said he didn’t know what his future held, I was thinking “Yup–you’re moving on…and good for you”. The only one from that place that I figured would stay in the business is Rod Daily…and in his case, he would fuck a tub of cottage cheese as long as a check was attached.

  13. No wonder a lot of the porn performers from NDS quit the buiz. At NDS they were paid for lackluster performances and now they are expected to amp up their game for the same or even less money? Don’t let the door hit ya’ on your ass on the way out.

  14. I really don’t get all the hate for this guy. Sam has always seemed pretty humble and sincere and genuinely nice. He has stated many times that he is bisexual, and just because he never bottomed doesn’t mean that he wasn’t telling the truth (do we claim Michael Lucas isn’t gay because he never bottoms?). Just because he worked for a studio that everyone hates isn’t a reason to hate on him personally (Paul Wagner works there too, and we all love him). I for one hope that Sam isn’t done with the business, and that we get to see more of him in the future – from a better studio this time.

    Happy Thanksgiving, everybody. :)

    1. what are you thinking

      Michael Lucas is accepted as gay because he has a male partner(which he leeches from, I digress), he openly questions and challenges those who have notions against gay rights, and has escorted for men on the side. I don’t think many people would doubt that he is gay. I may think many things about Michael Lucas, and disagree with him politically and philosophically, but I wouldn’t say he is a closet case.

      What most are complaining about are behaviors that contradict beliefs and statements. A cognitive dissonance. A good example of this is Matt Sanchez. For a while, Sanchez worked in gay porn, pursued men romantically off set, and allegedly escorted with guys, before becoming a conservative pundit renouncing gays and telling the public that we are predators. His justification for this complete reversal of attitude, is that gays used HIM and treated him with no regard. Wow, no ownership of behavior there. Plus, I get the sense he had felt rejection and heartbreak from his choice in working in porn and now he is a bitter queen.

      1. To be fair, Sammy has stated multiple times that he’s Bottomed many times before in his private life and the reason he doesn’t do it in NDS is because he isn’t able to keep up a professional quality/ cums too fast. I can get the feeling of people lying about their sexuality because it’s so much rooted in gay porn, but I believe he’s pretty genuine in this because if he was straight with his attitude, lord knows NDS wouldn’t push him to fuck dudes! (They’d have him dry hump and complain on camera like CC does)

        I like Samuel, but I feel like you can’t do this job forever (well… some do, but), so him moving on with his life is a good thing, and I wish him all the best with much love (I also hate how he was treated), but I wish he’d do his fans a solid and bottom for one video.

        1. what are you thinking...

          He has unequivocally stated on several occasions and interviews that he doesn’t like to bottom or date men. Where Where does he say it contrariwise to this? links please.

  15. i met him at a trade event, had a little chat, introduced him to a girl who was interested in him, and off they went.. nice guy, hope he works out his future ok

  16. Don’t worry too much, they always come back because it’s “easy money”…well easier than doing a 9-5 job that is.

    Anyway we’ll probably see Samuel coming back and doing just one more video then he’ll retire again
    Then he’ll come back stating that he’s escorting now and doing a few films then he’ll leave again
    Then he’ll come back saying that he’s now a serious actor and will be doing porn only “on the side”
    Then he’ll start a Kickstarter campaign for a new movie done by him that will be “a different kind of porn..a more artful porn”
    Then he’ll get David Forest to rep him and he’ll say that he’s not doing porn anymore and he’s not gay nor bi-sexual nor straight
    Then he’ll have a Twitter meltdown and start his own porn site saying that porn was the only thing his heart truly longs for

    So we’re still a long ways away from seeing the end yet…

  17. It doesn’t say anywhere that he actually got the job, unless I missed something. Oh well. I’m not really going to miss this guy. I mean yes he was attractive, and he was an ok performer but he didn’t really stick out much from the rest of the shit at NDS.

  18. He’ll be back, I always got the douche vibe from this guy and he’s probably doing all this for attention. Didn’t he also say he was in porn to pay for school? Strange.

  19. I’m sure the manager knows who he is, and that is probably why he has been hired as the assistant manager. duh.

    The after-work shenanigans in the stock room, when the manager drops to his knees to “service” the assistant manager’s big cock will likely lead ‘ol Sammy to being Employee of the Month in not time flat (all puns intended).

    1. Is it inappropriated? Maybe because we only saw ” Sammy ” do it in the past as a way to earn money. It’s his ” Curriculum Vitae ” and the references he can give to his new boss are the ‘work’ at NDS, unless he has other 9 to 5 work ( … I doubt. Who knows? )The only thing we know he can manage well is his tool and the position as an assistant manager he aplied for at Pepboys is about cars not assholes…As we know nothing about Sammy’s life let’s pretend things will be like Butch Harris so inappropriated described. It’s more fanny.

  20. Zach are you sure that bringing up the name of the company in the blog title is a good idea??

    The pepboys people will most likely hear of this eventually , I hope he doesn’t get fired the same way Kurt wild was.

    1. Samuel posted the name of the company he was going to work for in Twitter. He has also posted the name of the city he lives in and photos of his house on Twitter. I don’t think he cares.

    2. Well, when you are a one note performer, who doesn’t do anything outside of blowjobs or topping, and never bottom at ALL… you become old news, fast.

      And yeah, of course Samuel wouldn’t feel “ill will” towards NDS, as they basically took money from its pseudo-gay porn and used it towards straight and bi performers to fuck girls. Few of them bottomed and none of them showed versatility.

      NDS spoiled them, and now they can’t find jobs with actual gay productions that suit their desires…fucking chicks.

      And Samuel didn’t get called back for another interview for Pepboys, must be a bad week for him!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 50 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Scroll to Top